Shuttle Mediation: What It Is, How It Works and What to Watch Out For

Picture of Anna Vollans

Anna Vollans

Founder of Vollans Mediation

Shuttle Mediation

Shuttle Mediation: What It Is, How It Works and What to Watch Out For

Most people picture family mediation as sitting across a table from their former partner with a mediator in the middle. That is one way of doing it, but it’s not the only way. Shuttle mediation, sometimes called separate-spaces mediation, is an approach where you and your former partner do not meet in the same room at all. Instead, the mediator moves between you, either physically between rooms in the same building, or virtually whilst on a video call.

At Vollans Mediation, we offer shuttle mediation both in person at our Headingley office and online via Zoom. For some clients and some situations, it is the right approach. For others, it’s not. This post explains how it works, when it might be appropriate, and, importantly, some things you need to understand clearly before you agree to it.

How shuttle mediation works

In shuttle mediation, you and your former partner are kept entirely separate throughout the session. If you are meeting in person, you will be in different rooms, you will not see each other in reception, in corridors, or at any point during the session. If you are mediating online, you will each be in a separate private video call with the mediator.

The mediator moves between you, spending time with each of you in turn, listening to what you want to say and then carrying the key points of that conversation to the other person. They then bring back a response and the process continues in this way until the session ends or an agreement is reached.

The mediator is not a go-between in a simple messaging sense. They are actively facilitating a process, helping each of you to articulate what you want to say, identifying where there may be common ground and helping both of you understand what the other is trying to communicate. That said, they are doing all of this without you ever being in the same space as your former partner.

Sessions in shuttle format typically take longer than joint sessions covering the same ground, because the mediator needs to travel between you and because each exchange takes more time when it is relayed rather than direct. This is worth factoring into your expectations about how many sessions you might need.

When shuttle mediation might be appropriate

Shuttle mediation is not the default approach. Joint sessions, where both of you are in the same room or the same video call together, are the standard format for family mediation and for good reason. Direct communication, managed by a skilled mediator, is generally the most efficient and effective way to work through the issues.

There are, however, situations where shuttle mediation may be more appropriate.

Where there are concerns about safety or coercive control. If there is a history of domestic abuse, coercive or controlling behaviour, or significant fear of the other person, being in the same space, even with a mediator present, may not be safe or appropriate. Shuttle mediation allows the process to proceed without any physical proximity. This should always be discussed carefully with the mediator in advance.

Where the level of conflict makes joint sessions unproductive. Sometimes the dynamic between two people is so charged that joint sessions generate more heat than progress. If conversations consistently break down, if one person is consistently unable to speak without becoming distressed or aggressive, or if the presence of the other person is causing significant anxiety, shuttle may allow more productive conversations to take place.

Where one or both of you feel unable to speak freely in front of the other. Some people find it genuinely difficult to articulate their position in front of their former partner. The pressure of the room or anxiety about how the other person will react can make it hard to think clearly or communicate effectively. A separate space can help some people find their voice.

Where it is used for part of the process. Shuttle mediation does not have to be an all-or-nothing choice. Sometimes a session will begin jointly and move into shuttle format if a particular issue becomes difficult. Sometimes shuttle is used for one session and joint sessions resume afterwards. The mediator will guide this based on what is working.

Disadvantages of shuttle mediation

Shuttle mediation has some real drawbacks. Sessions take much longer, because nothing is said directly. The mediator has to move between you and pass on what each of you says in both directions, and that adds time to the process and often cost too.

It also doesn’t help you and your former partner learn to talk to each other. One of the wider benefits of joint mediation is that it can help you start communicating better which matters a great deal if you’ll be co-parenting. Shuttle mediation doesn’t build that in the same way.

There’s also more room for misunderstanding. When everything goes through the mediator nuance can get lost, the emphasis can shift, or a point can land differently from how it was meant. In joint sessions, you both hear the same words at the same time.

Some people find the process slower and harder to follow. Not being in the room while the other person is speaking can feel frustrating or unsettling because you’re relying on the mediator’s account of what was said instead of hearing it yourself.

Finally, shuttle mediation doesn’t suit every situation. Where the issues are complex and need you to solve problems together, such as detailed financial negotiations, it can make the process unwieldy. Some things really are better worked through with both of you in the same conversation.

Three things you need to understand clearly before agreeing to shuttle mediation

These three points are important enough that we want to be direct about them. They do not mean shuttle mediation cannot work – it can, and for some clients it is the right approach. But you should go into it with a clear understanding of both.

Important to understand #1

The mediator is not expressing their own opinion, they are passing on what the other person has said.  In shuttle mediation, everything you hear about what the other person is saying comes through the mediator. It can be tempting to read meaning into how the mediator says something: their tone, their word choices, the way they frame what the other person has said. It is easy to start wondering: is this what my former partner actually said or is this the mediator’s interpretation? Does the mediator think this is a good idea or a bad one?  A skilled mediator is trained to pass on what each person has said accurately and neutrally, without adding their own views, steering either person towards a particular outcome or colouring the message with their own opinion. That is a fundamental part of their professional obligation. If you ever feel that what you are hearing does not sound like something your former partner would actually say or that the mediator seems to be nudging you in a particular direction, you are entitled to say so. You can ask the mediator to clarify exactly what was said. A good mediator will welcome this. If you have concerns about how the process is being conducted, you should always feel free to raise this.

Important to understand #2

Shuttle mediation is not confidential between you and the mediator. What you say in your room can be shared with the other person.  This is one of the most commonly misunderstood aspects of shuttle mediation and it matters enormously.  People sometimes assume that because they are in a separate room speaking privately with the mediator, what they say is confidential and that the mediator is keeping their secrets. This is not how it works. Remember, the mediator is not acting for you. They are impartial and their role is to help both of you move towards agreement, which means sharing relevant information between you.  If you tell the mediator something in a private session (about your financial position, your priorities, your concerns, or your bottom line), you should assume that information may be passed to the other person. If you are in doubt about what will and will not be shared, ask the mediator directly at the start of the process. A good mediator will explain their approach to information-sharing in shuttle sessions clearly before you begin.

Important to understand #3

After each mediation session, the mediator will prepare a Mediation Record. The Mediation Record is not a transcript of everything that was said. It sets out the main points, any progress made and any proposals being considered and it’s written in a way that helps both of you move towards agreement. In joint sessions you hear the whole conversation, so it’s usually easy to see how the mediator has drawn it together and why some things are given more weight than others. In shuttle mediation that’s harder to see. You only hear part of the conversation, so when you read the record you may feel that some of what you said has been left out, or that the other person’s points have been given more room. The mediator summarises what both of you have said in the same way. They pick out what matters most for reaching agreement and leave out detail that doesn’t move things forward and they do this impartially for both of you.

Things to think about before agreeing to shuttle mediation

  • Is shuttle mediation being suggested for the right reasons? It is most appropriate where there are genuine safety concerns or where the joint format has been tried and is not working. It is not simply a more comfortable alternative to joint sessions.
  • Do you understand how information will be shared? Ask the mediator directly at the start how they handle information that one person shares in a separate session. What will they pass on? What will they keep private? Make sure you are clear before you say anything you would not want the other person to know.
  • Are you comfortable that what you will hear about the other person’s position is an accurate account of what they said? If at any point you are not, say so. You are entitled to ask the mediator to be more specific about what was said.
  • Have you considered whether joint sessions might be possible, even if they feel daunting? Shuttle mediation is a legitimate choice, but joint sessions, with a skilled mediator managing the dynamic, are often more efficient and build better foundations for ongoing co-parenting communication.
  • If safety is the reason for shuttle, has this been properly assessed? Safety concerns should be discussed in detail at the MIAM stage. Shuttle mediation is a tool that can help where there are concerns but it is not a substitute for a proper safety assessment.
  • Are you prepared for the process to take longer? Shuttle sessions cover less ground per hour than joint sessions. Factor this into your expectations about timescales and costs.

Shuttle mediation at Vollans Mediation

We discuss the format that is most appropriate for your situation at the MIAM stage. If shuttle mediation is what you need, we will explain exactly how we approach information sharing and what you can expect from the process before we begin. If you have questions or concerns at any point during shuttle sessions, we encourage you to raise them directly with us.

Call us on 0113 213 3662, email info@vollansmediation.co.uk, or visit www.vollansmediation.co.uk to find out more or to book a MIAM.

We are always happy to answer any questions and help you understand your options. There is no pressure to go ahead with anything.

Share this post

Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn